---
title: "TestDaF TDN 3 Speaking Task 5: Weighing up alternatives and advising"
description: "Oral Expression Task 5 in the TestDaF (TDN 3): weighing up alternatives and advising. Format, strategy, common mistakes and a worked example with answer."
canonical: "https://prepliq.com/en/practice-test/testdaf-german-tdn3/speaking/part-5"
url: "https://prepliq.com/en/practice-test/testdaf-german-tdn3/speaking/part-5.md"
locale: "en"
provider: "TestDaF"
level: "TDN 3"
alternates:
  de: "https://prepliq.com/de/modelltest/testdaf-deutsch-tdn3/sprechen/teil-5.md"
  en: "https://prepliq.com/en/practice-test/testdaf-german-tdn3/speaking/part-5.md"
  fr: "https://prepliq.com/fr/examen-blanc/testdaf-allemand-tdn3/expression-orale/partie-5.md"
  it: "https://prepliq.com/it/simulazione-esame/testdaf-tedesco-tdn3/parlato/parte-5.md"
  es: "https://prepliq.com/es/modelo-de-examen/testdaf-aleman-tdn3/expresion-oral/parte-5.md"
---

# TestDaF TDN 3 Speaking Task 5 – Weighing up alternatives and advising

> Oral Expression Task 5 in the TestDaF (TDN 3): weighing up alternatives and advising. Format, strategy, common mistakes and a worked example with answer.

## Key takeaways

- You weigh up two alternatives and give someone advice.
- Name pros and cons of both options and recommend one.

- Task type: Weighing up alternatives and advising
- Focus: Weighing up & advising

## What this part tests

Task 5 tests whether you can weigh up two alternatives and give someone justified advice.

You name pros and cons of both options, weigh them up and recommend one at the end – with a justification.

What matters is a structured weighing up of both sides and a clear, justified piece of advice.

**What you practice:** Weighing up alternatives, Naming pros and cons, Advising

## How to approach it

1. Grasp the two alternatives.
2. Name pros and cons of the first option.
3. Name pros and cons of the second option.
4. Weigh up which option prevails.
5. Give clear, justified advice (“An deiner Stelle würde ich …”).

## Example task with answer

A short example in the same format: the situation and a model answer.

**Aufgabe:** Eine Freundin überlegt, ob sie im Wohnheim oder in einer WG wohnen soll. Wägen Sie ab und geben Sie ihr einen Rat.

- Model answer:
  - Answer: Beide Möglichkeiten haben ihre Vor- und Nachteile. Im Wohnheim ist die Miete meist günstiger und du wohnst nah am Campus, aber die Zimmer sind oft klein und die Wartelisten lang. In einer WG hast du mehr Kontakt und oft schönere Zimmer, allerdings ist es meist teurer. An deiner Stelle würde ich zuerst versuchen, einen Platz im Wohnheim zu bekommen, weil du dort am Anfang Geld sparst. Wenn das nicht klappt, ist eine WG eine gute Alternative. — The answer weighs up both options with pros and cons and gives a clear, justified piece of advice – exactly what Task 5 expects.

## Practice: test yourself

Ein Freund kann nach dem Bachelor entweder direkt einen Master beginnen oder erst ein Praktikum machen. Er fragt dich um Rat.

- Which sentence weighs up and advises?
  - a) Ein Master direkt bringt dich schneller zum Abschluss, ein Praktikum gibt dir aber Praxiserfahrung. An deiner Stelle würde ich erst das Praktikum machen.
  - b) Mach einfach irgendwas.
  - c) Das ist mir egal.
  - Answer: a — Option a names pros and cons of both options and gives a clear piece of advice. b and c don’t weigh up and don’t advise.

## Common mistakes

- **Considering only one option:** Weigh up both alternatives, not just one.
- **Not advising:** Recommend one option at the end with a justification.
- **Advice without justification:** Justify your advice with the pros and cons.
- **Speaking too briefly:** Use the speaking time to weigh up both options.

## Tips

- Name pros and cons for each option.
- Use advice phrases like “An deiner Stelle würde ich …”.
- Justify your advice with the weighing up.

## Frequently asked questions

### What do I have to do in Task 5?

Weighing up alternatives and advising. Respond to the given situation and use the suitable phrases.

### How much preparation time do I have?

Only short preparation time. Quickly note keywords and a structure, then speak freely into the microphone.

### Do I speak with an examiner?

No. The Oral Expression is computer-based – you speak alone into the microphone, and your answer is recorded.

### What’s the best way to practice Task 5?

Practice this speech act with various situations, ideally out loud and recorded. A Prepliq mock grades your speaking automatically.

## Ready for the exam?

[Practice this part on Prepliq](https://prepliq.com/en/practice-test/testdaf-german-tdn3?action=start&sectionId=Oral%20Expression)

[TestDaF TDN 3 Speaking Task 5 – Weighing up alternatives and advising](https://prepliq.com/en/practice-test/testdaf-german-tdn3/speaking/part-5)